Legislation Details

File #: 23-090    Version: 1 Name: Enterprise Backup Solution
Type: Agenda Item Status: Approved
File created: 1/18/2023 In control: City Council
On agenda: 1/24/2023 Final action: 1/24/2023
Title: Request City Council to (1) Authorize a Contract in the Amount of $217,870.28 for an Enterprise Backup Solution to Nth Generation Computing, Inc., a California Corporation, for a Rubrik Backup appliance and Data Archive Cloud Services, (2) Authorize the City Manager or Designee to Execute All Documents. (ACTION)
Attachments: 1. Exhibit 1 - PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT, 2. Exhibit 2 - RFP Response, 3. Exhibit 3 - Cost Proposal

For City Council Meeting January 24, 2023

TO:                                           Honorable Mayor and City Council

APPROVAL:                      Arron Brown, Acting City Manager

FROM:                      Edgar Trenado, IT Manager

 

Title

Request City Council to (1) Authorize a Contract in the Amount of $217,870.28 for an Enterprise Backup Solution to Nth Generation Computing, Inc., a California Corporation, for a Rubrik Backup appliance and Data Archive Cloud Services, (2) Authorize the City Manager or Designee to Execute All Documents.

(ACTION)

 

Body

BACKGROUND

For the last several years, the City of Rialto has relied on a simple backup solution that lacks modern resilience and protections. This architecture is volatile and susceptible to external attacks. While attacks are not entirely preventable, IT best practices show that data needs to be kept in a secure place where recovery is achievable in the shortest amount of time. Over those years, the City's needs have significantly changed, and so has the threat landscape. Standards in technology have driven organizations to purchase more robust backup solutions with heightened security measures, and recovery has been at the forefront of mitigating "ransomware" for many government organizations. Additionally, the National Institute of Standards in Technology (Referred to as NIST) has provided guidelines and standards for a successful plan to mitigate such attacks and ultimately recover from them. One recommendation from NIST is a hybrid backup approach, where cloud infrastructure is used to set up an air-gapped immutable copy of the data. In the hybrid model, City's critical data resides both on-premises and in the cloud. The recommended Rubrik technology makes the recovery of data more manageable and reliable.

 

NIST recommends these guidelines to increase the chances for recovery of lost or corrupted data by following the 3-2-1 rule:

 

3 - Keep three copies of any important file: one primary and two backups.

2 - Keep the files on two different media types to protect data,

1 - Store one copy - or "air-gapped" - off-site (e.g., outside the business facility or cloud infrastructure).

 

 

ANALYSIS/DISCUSSION

A review of the current backup solution was completed using NIST guidelines, yielding some immediate needs that must be addressed. During this assessment, Staff determined that our current backup infrastructure must improve the following: a) Ransomware mitigation by facilitating the 3-2-1 rule, b) Faster recovery time if ever city data is compromised or needs recovery, c) an increased support service response times by having an established Service Level Agreement with the elected vendor for 24x7 support that is appropriate with City's current technology needs.

 

Many government entities have experienced ransomware and its destructive behavior, causing interruption of services to the public, data loss, and employee downtime. In each of the circumstances, it came down to a lack of security practices and functional backups. Because of this need, the City released RFP #23-004 to find the most secure and relevant solution for the City of Rialto's needs.

 

An enterprise-level backup appliance must meet NIST guidelines for business continuity and better mitigate service interruptions. A 60TB node will be placed in the City's data center, and a virtual node located strategically will allow for instant recovery of these virtual machines in case the first node is compromised or down; a third backup will be pushed to the cloud, where it is object locked (immutable and not on-premises) for continued support and higher mitigation of risk to the city data since data can be recovered from multiple locations. 

 

The proposed backup improvement will yield the following:

1.                     Three sets of data, two on-prem with a primary 60TB node, a second virtual node on-premises for instant recovery, and then a cloud backup of this data for archiving.

2.                     One file type will be disk in the primary and virtual node, and the cloud will be the sending type of media for backup, fulfilling guideline 2.

3.                     Redundant "air-gapped" and immutable backup to the cloud will fulfill guideline 3 as set by NIST. 

 

A request for proposal #23-004 yielded five competitive bids for the Enterprise Backup Solution, and this bid was conducted in September 2022. Two outside raters from City of Ontario, City of Fontana, as well as Assistant City Manager Arron Brown, IT Manager Edgar Trenado, and Network Engineer Jonathan Ballard from City of Rialto, conducted the rating for this bid. After a review of qualified vendors, Staff recommends that Nth Generations be selected to serve the City of Rialto with its enterprise backup solution. The agreement (Exhibit 1) contains the scope of work, installation guidelines, and the timeline for installation. Nth Generation understands the needs and requirements of the City of Rialto as expressed in Exhibit 2 (Nth Generation Computing, Inc's response to the request for proposal #23-004: Enterprise Backup Solution). Exhibit 3 has a price breakdown of the requested solution services and equipment. Additionally, Nth Generation was the least expensive responsive bid.

 

This agreement meets the City's expectations for an enterprise backup solution with the correct delivery services and methodologies for data recovery. 

 

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT

The proposed request is not a “Project” as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Pursuant to Section 15378(a), a “Project” means the whole of an action, which has a potential for resulting in either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment. According to section 15378(b), a project does not include: (5) Organization or administrative activities of governments that will not result in direct or indirect physical changes in the environment.

GENERAL PLAN CONSISTENCY

This action is consistent with Guiding Principles 1B and 3C in the General Plan:

 

1B - Essential community services must meet the needs and desires of our families.

 

3C - Our City government will lead by example and operate in an open, transparent, and responsible manner that meets the needs of the citizens and is a good place to do business.

 

LEGAL REVIEW

The City Attorney has reviewed and recommends approval of this staff report and contracts.

 

FINANCIAL IMPACT

Operating Budget Impact

 

Funds are budgeted and available for $217,870.28 in account 300-500-2152-3030, and this contract will cover all support and licensing for a 5-year term.

 

RECOMMENDATION

Request City Council to (1) Authorize a Contract in the Amount of $217,870.28 for an Enterprise Backup Solution to Nth Generation Computing, Inc., a California Corporation, for a Rubrik Backup appliance and Data Archive Cloud Services, (2) Authorize the City Manager or Designee to Execute All Documents.